Thursday, August 06, 2009

超級巨聲

其實並沒有專心地看畢整個節目,不過我覺得17分的何紫慧,和同樣得17分的何雁詩,兩人的表現比較特出。

住在天水圍的何紫慧唱得很好,十分有感情,真的看不出她只有14歲。

至於何雁詩特出的地方,就真系唔知佢有乜野咁好,Les Miserables 歌劇唔系人人唱得好,點解則田同古巨基在狂讚? 而且她跟不上拍子,最後無端端也可以得到加分,只能再次証明做無線D評判真系夠晒專業。

她唱完首歌一直還在哭,應該讚她富感情投入呢?還是她仍未能駕馭這歌曲呢? 大佬,真系你駛唔駛喊到咁慘呀? 而且我嫌她唱得太過柔弱,沒有唱歌劇的氣勢。

BTW, 作為主持的劉美君,講野也是甩甩漏漏。對歌手親切有餘,但主持經驗不足。

何紫慧像一位歌手,何雁詩只像一位表演的中學生。



何紫慧唱張惠妹的記得



何雁詩唱Les Miserables入面的 On My Own


我覺得歌劇唔容易唱,表演者在台上吐字清楚,包含無限感情,而且很有力量。

21 comments:

素顏天使™ said...

有雜誌已爆呢兩個都係伍樂城 (評判之一) 間音樂學院的學生, 仲要係愛徒果隻.....所以就算有做馬的情況, 都完全唔奇.

dd2 said...

香港終於又有番這類節目了. 我好少睇, 不過鍾意英國的Britain's Got Talent, esp. 主持人之一Simon Cowell, 不是因為他窒人唔駛本, 而是他敢講真心話, 有point又夠抵死, 而他的唱片工業背景亦adds to his credibility as one of the judges.

聽講亞視同類節目參賽者的水準比無記的好, 可惜是弱台.

台灣的同類節目出了個冠軍張芸京, 她參賽時唱Maroon Five的Makes Me Wonder和Radiohead的Creep, 表現出眾, 令我印象深刻, 尤其Radiohead廣受全球樂迷鍾愛, 她夠胆唱他們的頭號大熱作品又唱得到, 厲害!

張芸京/Makes Me Wonder雌雄莫辨版:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vkbqFmO6G68

張芸京/Creep激情版:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OiuO0B_dG80

Anonymous said...

何紫慧的衣著,跟梁文音未參加超級星光大道前,在另一個綜藝節目唱《記得》時的衣著有90%相似...(那條褲的顏色很少人會穿..)
哈哈
這完全是題外話啦
不過梁文音唱這首歌實在唱得好太多
有興趣的話你可以找找看=)

kath

肥貓 said...

無睇tvb, 不過有看atv, 挫強扶弱!!

Denzel Leung said...

梁弟兄,
記唔記得...
我地細細個個陣有個節目叫"聲寶之夜"?
係喎,你仲記唔記點彈鋼琴?

Xavier said...

HI dd2,

今屆冠軍張芸京我冇睇過喎,反而上屆的星光大道那位徐佳瑩唔錯喎,睇過佢唱"我愛你"同首身騎白馬...好正。好似系上面位素顏的BLOG都介紹過佢。

THANKS FOR THE Link. 一會去看:)

Xavier said...

Hi Kath,

咦,梁文音我都鐘意佢,冇聲過佢唱記得,不過佢屈居亞軍,我覺得比冠軍好,有機會會買埋佢都新CD :)

Xavier said...

Hi FC,

ATV的亞洲星光大道我都有睇,記憶中那位已經辭工的道路收費員唱得不錯:)

Xavier said...

呀梁弟兄,

舊年尾我老師大左肚之後(唔關我事),我都冇去學琴,而家都成大半年了,或者過兩個月等佢個仔大D先去上返堂啦。不過講真,我有本N年前的伍樂城的樂譜,仲未掉。

Xavier said...

Hi 素顏,

Oh.原來有內幕,唔怪之得伍樂城都冇乜出聲,不過何紫慧都好似做過幾多表演,youtube入面好多佢唱live的video。

Anonymous said...

這是梁文音唱記得的link,找不回之前看的那個節目,所以她的衣著跟香港那位參賽者並不相似呢
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NikzWqYWkFE

不知道你有沒有聽過一個叫曾軼可的女生,是超級女生的,她唱功不太好,但作的歌給人的感覺很特別,有興趣你也可以在youtube看一下

kath

el el said...

撇開參賽者質素,
主持和評判都已經不入流啦!
主持只說:將個台交俾你喇!
完全唔識控制氣氛;
評判也沒有建設性的話.
反而亞視的肥媽與吳國敬,
對於參賽者,對於觀眾,都有得著.

其實以上只是路過隨口O翕,
最想講O既係,
那個又高又帥又有思想的人離開我(們)了,
的確好傷心喔!
但願唔高唔帥的那位仁兄,
唔好捨我(們)而去.
唉,懷念那奇蹟的一夜,
五月廿五.

pandora said...

個何雁詩唱得無感情, 睇得出好緊張.

btw, Les Miserables唔係歌劇, 係musical音樂劇

聶秀康 said...

何紫惠真不像14歲啊!
樣子化妝都似廿五.六.
但唱得好又有感情,
反而主持沒水時常講錯又窒則田,古巨基又太感性.
沒有看亞視.

Xavier said...

Thanks kath for 梁文音'S LINK :)

Xavier said...

Hi elel,

無錯,系神奇的一夜.沙比射十二碼唔入再補中3:3,最後加時...真系歷歷在目。另一球好記得就後在自己的後半場射波,笠死龍門,好似仲系唔止一球系咁。

Xavier said...

Pandora,

Thanks. 但我都系唔識分兩者的分別... :)

Xavier said...

HI 聶,

系呀我都覺得何紫惠唔似14歲, 嚇左一跳。不過YOUTUBE有佢唔少的VIDEO都系唱LIVE表演, 都幾有水準.

梁巔巔 said...

Xavier 兄:

i. 劉美君好正!

ii. 總覺得呢種節目, 係現代版嘅歌唱比賽.

Xavier said...

梁兄,

WELCOME BACK WOR. 希望你一切順利啦.

:)

qishaya said...

abercrombie.us.com beautyWhere are some good spaces to find an Abercrombie Jeans Cologne magazine? One places is magazines. Many wellbeing and beauty magazines propose cologne and odor artifact reviews.Abercrombie Outerwear Some of them even have sample strips that you can open and actually get to smell the fragrance that they are reviewing for the invention line. Abercrombie Hoodies Another great place to find artifact reviews are Abercrombie Pant . EZines are online magazines and often sent to people in the transmit.Abercrombie Polo You can subscribe to artifact study eZines and You will find more information about the Wholesale actual belief jeans, Abercrombie Shirt many people are weird for export the jeans in fresh living.even cologne or scent eZines. Abercrombie fitch Men Many times you can demand from the editor of the eZine to do an exclusive type Shoes are very important to everyone, Our Abercrombie Tees will guard your feet. Abercrombie fitch Women of check for you.Abercrombie bag If you want to grip this effect line, you can ask them specifically to do an Abercrombie and Fitch Cologne review for you and the other readers. Abercrombie Slippers Most editors are forever looking for theme ideas and more than agreeble to help you out. Abercrombie Cap In their food. dealer, abercrombie and fitch (A&F), named the belt in a grievance. Abercrombie Scarves Employment law attorneys representing, Riam Dean, Abercrombie Shorts , cite disability discrimination in the ensemble and are claiming Dean is probable to persist for the next three living.Abercrombie and fitch, a New Albany, Ohio A&F trader, with over 300 food nationwide,Abercrombie And Fitch Jackets, is not unfamiliar with facing discrimination lawsuits. The clothing stored restrict has faced allegations in the gone for the Abercrombie Sweater giant

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails